What memory trusts

Agents, documents and people keep telling memory things. One story below shows what memory keeps, what it holds in question, and whom it listens to in a dispute.

Voices count, repeats do not.Each new independent source adds weight to a fact. A source that repeats itself ten times is still one voice.
The weaker does not push out the stronger.A new statement replaces an old one only on grounds at least as strong. Otherwise a dispute opens and the old fact stays in force.
Only the operator changes the operator's word.What the person with the operator key vouched for, agents cannot rewrite, however many of them agree.

A fact card

A customer may return any item within 14 days.
acceptedoperator-protected
Return policyDelivery rules
confidence0.75
strength100%
  1. Text and key. The first six words are highlighted: memory uses them to tell that two statements are about the same thing. “…within 14 days” and “…within 30 days” with the same opening dispute each other.
  2. Status. “Accepted” means someone vouched for the fact (the operator, a correction, a review). “Observation” means an agent recorded it on its own. A fact “confirmed” by a person and a “theorem” rank above all: they are never replaced automatically.
  3. Sources. Who stands behind the fact: documents, agents, reviewers. Only different ones count.
  4. Confidence. Starts at 0.70 (0.85 for policies and corrections); each new source adds 0.05.
  5. Strength. How fresh the fact is. Without confirmations it halves every 30 days; a fact that fades away goes to the archive.
  6. Operator protection. The operator recorded the fact, or it came from a document the operator vouched for.

The “Spoke” bike shop, March

The shop has several bots and one shared memory. Step through: on the left is what happened in real life, on the right is what memory holds afterwards. Changed cards are outlined. The ← → keys work too. The story is made up; the rules are real.

What happened

    What memory did

    struck-through means closed, not erased

    A new statement on the same key: what happens

    Memory asks four questions in order. The first “yes” settles it.

    1

    Is the old fact a theorem or confirmed by a person?

    Such facts count as settled.
    yes → a person decidesA dispute opens and will not resolve itself. Like a notarised record: it can be corrected, but only through the notary.
    2

    Does the new statement carry authority?

    The operator recorded it; it comes from a document marked “fact” or “refine”; it is a trusted agent's correction; or it comes from the same source as the old fact (a new version of the document, an agent correcting itself).
    yes → replaceThe old fact is closed with a date and stays in the history.
    3

    Does the operator stand behind the old fact?

    And the new one has no authority: an ordinary agent recorded it.
    yes → dispute until the operator rulesThe challenge never wins on its own, however many agents back it. After 7 days the dispute counts as overdue.
    4

    Are the new statement's grounds at least as strong?

    Compared like a league table: status first, then the number of distinct sources, then confidence. A full tie goes to the newcomer.
    yes → replace · no → disputeThe loser becomes a challenge. Each new source behind it re-weighs the two: once it catches up, it wins by itself.
    From the story, 8 and 9 March
    “…3 days” is standingobservation · 2 sources · 0.75
    “…5 days” arrives, weaker, disputeobservation · 1 source · 0.70
    “…5 days” after the check: a tie, it winsobservation · 2 sources · 0.75

    A document to check against: notes in the margin

    This is how an auditor checks a ledger: ticks and question marks in the margin, nothing rewritten in the ledger itself. A document uploaded for verification never becomes facts. Each of its lines gets one of three outcomes.

    Delivery rules, rev. 2
    ✓

    Delivery of an order to Rotterdam usually takes 5 days.Confirmed. The document stands behind the fact as one more source, once, however many lines match.

    ✓

    A customer may return any item within 14 days.Confirmed. If the fact came from this very document, it is not counted again.

    ?

    The pickup point in the city centre is open until 20:00.Disputed: memory says “until 21:00”. It goes into the report only. Memory does not change; the operator decides.

    —

    Gift wrapping is free on orders over €50.No match: memory has no such fact. The line does not become a new fact.

    Why the disputed line changes nothing: an ordinary agent may upload a document for verification too. If a dispute lowered confidence, any agent would get a lever against facts it never wrote. A document that looks like a prompt-injection attempt confirms nothing; it only reports.

    Three key roles

    Operator

    • Its records are protected
    • Replaces any fact except a theorem, without weighing
    • Settles disputes
    • Vouches for documents: “fact”, “refine”

    Trusted agent

    • A bot where the person has signed in with a password: the customer account
    • Its correction counts as the operator's word
    • Keeps protection but does not create it: correct an ordinary fact and it stays ordinary
    • A plain record counts like an agent's

    Agent

    • A bot in an open chat where anyone can write
    • Its facts live by the weight rule
    • Against an operator's fact it can only open a dispute
    • Can upload a document for verification or as reference

    Five ways to upload a document

    What happens to a document is decided by the mark the uploader sets, not by the file type.

    MarkIn real lifeWhat memory doesWho may
    factAn order signed by the managerAccepted facts at once, under operator protection, confidence 0.70Operator
    refineAn order amending an earlier oneFacts that replace old ones with the operator's authorityOperator
    verifyA reconciliation statementA report: confirmed / disputed / no match; no factsAnyone
    referenceA “for information” folderFull-text search only; never factsAnyone
    no markA letter that arrived in the mailboxChunks become “pending verification” facts (0.50) once search has used themAnyone

    What memory cannot do yet